A key member of your team hands in their notice. They’ve accepted an offer elsewhere. Your instinct, and often your partners’ instinct, is to counter: match the salary, improve the title, promise the things that should have happened months ago.

It’s understandable. In most cases, it’s also the wrong call.

Why counter-offers rarely work

Salary is rarely the real reason someone leaves. People don’t go through a job search, interviews and an awkward resignation for a modest pay rise. They do it because something isn’t working: progression, management, the quality of the work, recognition or culture.

A counter-offer deals with the symptom, not the cause. And it sends a message the person won’t forget: the firm knew they were worth more and waited until they were leaving to act.

In our experience, many people who accept a counter-offer are back on the market within the year, because nothing else has changed.

The cost to the practice

Counter-offers cost more than the pay rise. They set a precedent: the rest of the team learns that resigning is the way to get a raise. The person who stays is often less committed than before. They’ve seen what’s on offer elsewhere, and they know the firm was content to underpay them until it had to act.

There’s also partner time. Weeks spent managing a counter-offer are weeks not spent on clients or growth.

What to do instead

Practices that handle this well do two things.

First, they work on retention before anyone resigns: regular, direct conversations about progression, salaries benchmarked against the market every year, and development promises that are kept.

Second, when a good person does leave, they handle it well. A gracious exit and a good working relationship afterwards both matter. People who leave on good terms often come back, and they refer others.

When you’re the firm making the offer

The counter-offer is a risk on the other side too. We talk it through with candidates before they resign, so they’ve already decided what they’d say if their firm counters. That early conversation is the best protection there is.

A counter-offer is almost always a sign of something that could have been dealt with earlier. If you’d like to know where your salaries sit against the market, talk to us in confidence.