Whether to run a search on a retained or contingency basis comes up in most conversations we have with partners and HR leads about senior hiring. It’s usually framed as a question about cost. It’s more useful to treat it as a question about reach and risk.

How contingency works

On contingency, you pay only when someone starts. The recruiter searches their network and puts forward candidates who fit. There’s no upfront cost, and if nobody is hired, there’s no fee.

Contingency works well when the brief is clear, the market has active candidates, and you’re happy for the search to focus on the people a recruiter already knows. When several agencies work the same role, though, the incentive shifts towards speed: whoever sends a CV first is most likely to be paid. That can mean the same candidate reaching you from two directions, and less time spent understanding what you need.

How retained search works

On a retained search, you engage one firm exclusively and pay the fee in stages, starting at the outset. That commitment pays for a full search: mapping everyone credible who could do the role, approaching people who aren’t looking, assessing them in depth and managing the process through to start date.

Retained search makes sense when the role is hard to fill, the right person is unlikely to be looking, the search needs to be confidential, or the cost of a wrong hire is high. Partner and Director searches nearly always fall into that group. So can a Manager in a niche service line, or any role you’ve already tried to fill without success.

Choosing, at any level

We offer both, at any level from Part-Qualified to Partner, and the choice is yours. As a rough guide:

Either way, we benchmark the salary at the briefing stage. If it won’t attract the level you need, it’s better to know before the search starts than three months into it.

What a retained search adds

Our retained searches include market insight as the search progresses and, at the end, a guide to how your firm is perceived in the market, which is useful well beyond the one hire. We have a 100% success rate on retained searches.

The model matters, but the person running the search matters more. One consultant runs each of our searches from brief to start date. See how both options work, or talk to us about a role.